Google's verified boot support consists of:
When using vboot, the root-of-trust is basically the read-only portion of the SPI flash. The following items factor into the trust equation:
The firmware is typically protected using the write-protect pin on the SPI flash part and setting some of the write-protect bits in the status register during manufacturing. The protected area is platform specific and for x86 platforms is typically 1/4th of the SPI flash part size. Because this portion of the SPI flash is hardware write protected, it is not possible to update this portion of the SPI flash in the field, without altering the system to eliminate the ground connection to the SPI flash write-protect pin. Without hardware modifications, this portion of the SPI flash maintains the manufactured state during the system's lifetime.
Several sections are added to the firmware layout to support vboot:
The following sections describe the various portions of the flash layout.
The read-only section contains a coreboot file system (CBFS) that contains all of the boot firmware necessary to perform recovery for the system. This firmware is typically protected using the write-protect pin on the SPI flash part and setting some of the write-protect bits in the status register during manufacturing. The protected area is typically 1/4th of the SPI flash part size and must cover the entire read-only section which consists of:
The GBB area is part of the read-only section. This area contains a 4096 or 8192 bit public root RSA key that is used to verify the VBLOCK area to obtain the firmware signing key.
The recovery firmware is contained within a coreboot file system and consists of:
The recovery firmware is written during manufacturing and typically contains code to write the storage device (eMMC device or hard disk). The recovery image is usually contained on a socketed device such as a USB flash drive or an SD card. Depending upon the payload firmware doing the recovery, it may be possible for the user to interact with the system to specify the recovery image path. Part of the recovery is also to write the A and B areas of the SPI flash device to boot the system.
The read/write sections contain an area which contains the firmware signing key and signature and an area containing a coreboot file system with a subset of the firmware. The firmware files in FW_MAIN_A and FW_MAIN_B are:
The firmware subset enables most issues to be fixed in the field with firmware updates. The firmware files handle memory and most of silicon initialization. These files also produce the tables which get passed to the operating system.
The read/write sections exist in one of three states:
|
Where is this state information written?
CMOS? RW_NVRAM? RW_FWID_* |
Firmware updates are handled by the operating system by writing any read/write section that is not in the "successfully booted" state. Upon the next reboot, vboot determines the section to boot. If it finds one in the "ready to boot" state then it attempts to boot using that section. If the boot fails then vboot marks the section as invalid and attempts to fall back to a read/write section in the "successfully booted" state. If vboot is not able to find a section in the "successfully booted" state then vboot enters recovery mode.
Only the operating system is able to transition a section from the "ready to boot" state to the "successfully booted" state. The transition is typically done after after the operating system has been running for a while indicating that successful boot was possible and the operating system is stable.
Note that as long as the SPI write protection is in place then the system is always recoverable. If the flash update fails then the system will continue to boot using the previous read/write area. The same is true if coreboot passes control to the payload or the operating system and then the boot fails. In the worst case, the SPI flash gets totally corrupted in which case vboot fails the signature checks and enters recovery mode. There are no times where the SPI flash is exposed and the reset vector or part of the recovery firmware gets corrupted.
The following Kconfig values need to be selected to enable vboot:
The starting stage needs to be specified by selecting either VBOOT_STARTS_IN_BOOTBLOCK or VBOOT_STARTS_IN_ROMSTAGE.
If vboot starts in bootblock then vboot may be built as a separate stage by selecting VBOOT_SEPARATE_VERSTAGE. Additionally, if static RAM is too small to fit both verstage and romstage then selecting VBOOT_RETURN_FROM_VERSTAGE enables bootblock to reuse the RAM occupied by verstage for romstage.
Non-volatile flash is needed for vboot operation. This flash area may be in CMOS, the EC, or in a read/write area of the SPI flash device. Select one of the following:
More non-volatile storage features may be found in src/vboot/Kconfig.
A TPM is also required for vboot operation. TPMs are available in drivers/i2c/tpm and drivers/pc80/tpm.
In addition to adding the coreboot files into the read-only region, enabling vboot causes the build script to add the read/write files into coreboot file systems in FW_MAIN_A and FW_MAIN_B.
The follow command script is an example of how to sign the coreboot image file. This script is used on the Intel Galileo board and creates the GBB area and inserts it into the coreboot image. It also updates the VBLOCK areas with the firmware signing key and the signature for the FW_MAIN firmware. More details are available in 3rdparty/vboot/README.
#!/bin/sh
#
# The necessary tools were built and installed using the following commands:
#
# pushd 3rdparty/vboot
# make
# sudo make install
# popd
#
# The keys were made using the following command
#
# 3rdparty/vboot/scripts/keygeneration/create_new_keys.sh \
# --4k --4k-root --output $PWD/keys
#
#
# The "magic" numbers below are derived from the GBB section in
# src/mainboard/intel/galileo/vboot.fmd.
#
# GBB Header Size: 0x80
# GBB Offset: 0x611000, 4KiB block number: 1553 (0x611)
# GBB Length: 0x7f000, 4KiB blocks: 127 (0x7f)
# COREBOOT Offset: 0x690000, 4KiB block number: 1680 (0x690)
# COREBOOT Length: 0x170000, 4KiB blocks: 368 (0x170)
#
# 0x7f000 (GBB Length) = 0x80 + 0x100 + 0x1000 + 0x7ce80 + 0x1000
#
# Create the GBB area blob
# Parameters: hwid_size,rootkey_size,bmpfv_size,recoverykey_size
#
gbb_utility -c 0x100,0x1000,0x7ce80,0x1000 gbb.blob
#
# Copy from the start of the flash to the GBB region into the signed flash
# image.
#
# 1553 * 4096 = 0x611 * 0x1000 = 0x611000, size of area before GBB
#
dd conv=fdatasync ibs=4096 obs=4096 count=1553 \
if=build/coreboot.rom of=build/coreboot.signed.rom
#
# Append the empty GBB area to the coreboot.rom image.
#
# 1553 * 4096 = 0x611 * 0x1000 = 0x611000, offset to GBB
#
dd conv=fdatasync obs=4096 obs=4096 seek=1553 if=gbb.blob \
of=build/coreboot.signed.rom
#
# Append the rest of the read-only region into the signed flash image.
#
# 1680 * 4096 = 0x690 * 0x1000 = 0x690000, offset to COREBOOT area
# 368 * 4096 = 0x170 * 0x1000 = 0x170000, length of COREBOOT area
#
dd conv=fdatasync ibs=4096 obs=4096 skip=1680 seek=1680 count=368 \
if=build/coreboot.rom of=build/coreboot.signed.rom
#
# Insert the HWID and public root and recovery RSA keys into the GBB area.
#
gbb_utility \
--set --hwid='Galileo' \
-r $PWD/keys/recovery_key.vbpubk \
-k $PWD/keys/root_key.vbpubk \
build/coreboot.signed.rom
#
# Sign the read/write firmware areas with the private signing key and update
# the VBLOCK_A and VBLOCK_B regions.
#
3rdparty/vboot/scripts/image_signing/sign_firmware.sh \
build/coreboot.signed.rom \
$PWD/keys \
build/coreboot.signed.rom
The reset vector exist in the read-only area and points to the bootblock entry point. The only copy of the bootblock exists in the read-only area of the SPI flash. Verstage may be part of the bootblock or a separate stage. If separate then the bootblock loads verstage from the read-only area and transfers control to it.
Upon first boot, verstage attempts to verify the read/write section A. It gets the public root key from the GBB area and uses that to verify the VBLOCK area in read-write section A. If the VBLOCK area is valid then it extracts the firmware signing key (1024-8192 bits) and uses that to verify the FW_MAIN_A area of read/write section A. If the verification is successful then verstage instructs coreboot to use the coreboot file system in read/write section A for the contents of the remaining boot firmware (romstage, postcar, ramstage and the payload).
If verification fails for the read/write area and the other read/write area is not valid vboot falls back to the read-only area to boot into system recovery.
Google's Chromebooks have some special features:
Developer mode allows the user to use coreboot to boot another operating system. This may be a another (beta) version of Chrome OS, or another flavor of GNU/Linux. Use of developer mode does not void the system warranty. Upon entry into developer mode, all locally saved data on the system is lost. This prevents someone from entering developer mode to subvert the system security to access files on the local system or cloud.
Chromebooks have a write-protect screw which provides the ground to the write-protect pin of the SPI flash. Google specifically did this to allow the manufacturing line and advanced developers to re-write the entire SPI flash part. Once the screw is removed, any firmware may be placed on the device. However, accessing this screw requires opening the case and voids the system warranty!
Modified: 2 May 2017